Saturday, November 21, 2026

Not One Jot, Except...

Old Covenant legalists insist that God's law remains unchanged, but they can't seem to agree on which laws we're supposed to keep, which ones have disappeared, or how the whole thing is supposed to work. Apparently, not one jot or tittle has changed, except for all the exceptions.

I was once an Armstrongist. I genuinely thought they had their doctrine correct. I lived it, taught it, sacrificed so much for it, and will live the rest of my days with the repercussions of it. I never saw, or rather never admitted, the flaws in the system until I gave myself permission to ask questions. I left the group after the inconsistencies became too numerous and serious to pretend like they did not matter.

What really floors me these days is that the issues just keep right on coming; not only from Armstrongism but from other legalist groups.

They all say, "The law! The law!" But they don't agree with one another on why we are all bound to the law, or even what laws we are bound to. They explain their competing systems in many ways which do not agree with one another. Does the law apply to us because we join physical Israel, or does the law apply to us because it applies to everyone? One says we are bound to all the moral law and some of the ceremonial law, another says we are bound to the Ten Commandments only and some of the ceremonial law, and yet another says the Ten Commandments are the whole law.
"...just not THAT law."

This is the kind of issue I want to examine today. Because it keeps coming up, over and over again.

NOTHING HAS CHANGED EXCEPT WHAT HAS CHANGED

I will start by reminding you of my post "One Jot or One Tittle", where we reviewed one of Sabbatarianism's favorite proof-texts:

(MAT. 5: 17-18) 17 Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill. 18 For assuredly, I say to you, til heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from the law til all is fulfilled.

Not one jot or one tittle. Not one cross of the T or dot of the I. Sabbatarians believe this selection means all the whole law is still in force, all of it, 'til heaven and earth pass away.
...except for that 97% of the law that they believe is not necessary. Every T and I, except for those ones. Naturally.

The image says the law is the truth and asks, "How can anyone claim obeying His law is no longer necessary?"
3% of the time, the law is unchanged every time.

Herbert Armstrong himself, in the Plain Truth Magazine, September 1959, p.5, quotes Matthew 5:17-18, but he immediately deflects to it referring to the Ten Commandments. Garner Ted Armstrong used it to support tithing. Herman Hoeh used it to claim the Bible is accurate and God's word has been preserved. Rod Meredith used it to say we can keep the law with the help of the Holy Spirit.

Apparently, Matthew 5:17-18 can mean anything we need it to.

But at the end of the day, Jesus only leaves two options: either all the law is 100% in force, or all the law has been fulfilled. If any point has passed from the law, and most legalist groups say it has, then guess what that means ... all has been fulfilled. Sabbatarians take both options.

I know someone will say to me, "Fulfilled does not mean removed." This is absolutely correct.  ' Fulfill' and 'remove' are not the same. Jesus lived to fulfill it and died to remove it. But this objection demonstrates my point. 

Jesus said He came to fulfill it. He did. Jesus, the True Israel, kept it all on Israel's behalf. He fulfilled the law. He is the law-keeper. If it is not fulfilled, then what part(s) did Jesus miss, who will fulfill it, and when?
He is also the primary party to the Old Covenant. When He died, that Covenant dissolved. The phrase "til all is fulfilled" implies it will be removed after it is fulfilled. If the law cannot be removed, then why does everyone have parts they've removed? Not a jot or tittle can be removed until it's all fulfilled ... and yet we've removed whole swaths, therefore we all agree it has been fulfilled. Yes?
In all actuality, Sabbatarians are trying to have this one both ways and neither.

Chief among removed laws are the ones that make it abundantly clear the law as for Israel alone. The Ten Commandments were specifically for Israel, the people who were saved from Egypt and were on their way to the land the Lord was giving them. It's right there in the first sentence of the Decalogue. Or just look at the fifth Commandment:

(EXO. 20:12) Honor your father and your mother, that your days may be long upon the land which the Lord your God is giving you.

Is it a moral and good thing to honor your father and mother? Yes! But will it lead to your land-blessings in Israel? Not so much. We cannot simply pretend like the second half of that Commandment does not exist.

The Ten were written for and given to Israel. If the law is not changed, then this reality is not changed. These Gentile Sabbatarians must first make fundamental alterations in the law to get it to apply to the whole world and themselves before they can turn around and accuse everyone of not keeping the list of laws they created for themselves. Except it isn't theirs to make lists from.

Either the law is 100% in force, or it isn't. But if it isn't, then we cannot quote Matthew like it is. Claiming fulfilled does not mean destroyed is correct, but rather contradictory when taking both sides at the same time.

RITUALLY SACRIFICED

Another person told me this:

"The law of sin and death didn't change; only the source of the blood that atones for our sin."

To which I replied, "That's a change." And a big one.
Do you see how this person has taken both sides? The law has not changed at all ...except where it has. 

The point in that quote, you see, is that the "ceremonial law" is gone. Old Covenant legalists do not want the whole law, only some laws. So, they work hard to keep the laws they want and jettison the laws they do not want. Because it's useful, they accept the division of the law into moral, ceremonial, and national laws, Then they remove the ceremonial and national ones. The ceremonial ones were replaced by Jesus, they say, and the national ones were only for Israel. (Except they were all only for Israel, but I digress.) But the moral ones stay unchanged, they say.

Which ones are the moral laws? I have yet to witness any Sabbatarian provide a coherent definition for what a "moral law" even is. They tell us the moral laws remain in force. Fantastic! Which are those, exactly? They won't say. I tried to research it on my own. The Bible doesn't say. Why not? Because the Bible does not divide the law into these three categories, and the individual laws do not always fit those three categories neatly. What even is a "moral law", exactly? They won't commit to a definition. Mainly because that definition would exclude the Sabbath day. (But that is for another article.)

Even though the individual laws do have those qualities, I do not subscribe to splitting the law into three categories. Why not? Because the Bible never recognizes these as legal categories. The Bible never says anything of the sort. The body of Old Covenant law is a single, indivisible whole and the 613 laws are the terms of that covenant. Even though the individual laws do have those qualities (not all fit neatly), that is no excuse to use those qualities to divide the Covenant up and toss out parts.

Hey! What happened to Matthew 5:17-18?

Someone might say to me, "But Hebrews makes it clear the ceremonial parts are gone." OK. I agree, it does. And they are. I believe it shows a lot more than that. It shows the whole covenant was replaced.

And again, dividing the law up and tossing parts out is just a wordier way to say, "Not one jot or one tittle, except..."

WHAT'S ON THE INSIDE

Here is an actual quote pulled verbatim straight from social media:

"The New Covenant was never meant to be the death of the Torah. It was the internalizing of it. ... The Torah is not a shadow of the past; it is the light for our path, now shining from the inside out. That is the power of the New Covenant."

Translation: The power of the New Covenant is that it's exactly the same as the Old Covenant in every way, only fundamentally different.
Magnificent!

Disregard that this person writes Torah when they mean Old Covenant law. Torah is a lot more than law. A rookie mistake, but I'm not here to nitpick.

What I cannot simply disregard, however, is that I have yet to witness any Old Covenant legalist give a satisfactory explanation for what "the law, internalized" actually is, in the real world. For example, how do I, every seventh day, have physical rest internally? How do we build a booth internally? Do we internally sacrifice turtledoves? Do our tefillin shine through from the inside? Do we spiritually have a son of Aaron as our High Priest with a miter and ephod? How do we get fabrics inside of us, but then prevent them from mixing together?

In the real world, saying, "The letter of the Old Covenant law unchanged but it is inside us," is completely incoherent.

I took the quote above from a much longer statement. It was clear the intent was to say the New Covenant does nothing to remove the Old Covenant law. There is a problem with this: that must include ALL of the law, even the ceremonial and national laws, which have been tossed out.

You may think I'm being ridiculous in my questions above, and perhaps I am, but remember, I am not the one claiming the law has to be 100% intact and unchanged except that it's fundamentally changed and internalized. So, am I really being ridiculous, or am I merely pointing out the ridiculous?

If you want another way to understand the law being internalized, read "The Law Is Written On Our Hearts - Part I".

WHO SAT ON THE REMOTE?

Go ahead and ask an Old Covenant legalist about these internal incoherencies. All you will get is more incoherency. How do I know? Because I've been trying it for years.

Here is an actual quote pulled verbatim straight from social media. Someone mentioned that we must keep the Sabbath now because Isaiah says we will keep the Sabbath in the future. I mentioned about how Isaiah said we would ride chariots to collect Levites to serve at the temple, and asked if that means Christians should have the Levitical Priesthood with the Aaronic Priest today? They said:

"It's not an ending, but a pause. Even after Jesus returned to heaven the early Christians were still bringing offerings and sacrifices to the Temple."

So, the ceremonial law is not gone but on pause. Someone should tell that to the author of Hebrews. When we find the remote and finally un-pause, will we have two High Priests? 

This person's point was that there is no Temple, so we can't do those things today. That's not entirely correct. The Temple may be gone but the Levites went nowhere. There are parts of the law which require a Levite but do not require the Temple (e.g., unsolved murders, skin disease inspections, inspections for contamination of homes or clothes, etc)? What happens to these laws? Why are they on pause? And perhaps most pertinent of all, what happens to tithing? It was primarily for the Levites. How can a "Minister" accept tithes when it's supposed to be for the Levites, and those laws are not removed? Someone owes back payments!

The author mentioned James advising Paul to shave his head and pay for four men who had taken a vow, which we see in Acts 21. And, yes, there usually was some sort of sacrifice at the end of a vow (usually, but not always). There are several problem here:

  • What Jewish converts in Jerusalem were doing prior to the Temple's destruction is not an indicator of what everyone should be doing today, let alone when Christ returns.
  • Anyone who uses Acts 21 to claim the Jewish converts were zealous for the law and therefore we should be zealous for the law (which would be most if not all Sabbatarian groups), must remember that includes animal sacrifice.
  • This does not constitute an endorsement of animal sacrifice, or a Jewish Temple, or the human High Priest in the New Covenant era.
  • We cannot simply ignore that James was bluntly specific when he said, "But concerning the Gentiles who believe, we have written and decided that they should observe no such thing..." (v25). (For more, see "Acts 15 - What Was Debated?")

I remind you that this part of Isaiah 66 is a prophecy, and all prophetic interpretation is speculation (even my own). It is a terrible idea to build doctrine on speculation. Yet, I believe a literal interpretation falls completely apart if we approach it in a neutral way, without trying to force it to support a certain predetermined conclusion. We go into this in the post "The Sabbath Rest of Isaiah 66".

CONCLUSION

I trust by now that you see how this game is played. "The law is eternal and unchanged," but not the ceremonial law, the national law, the parts that specify Israel and exclude Gentiles, the parts that require a Temple, the parts that require a Levite (even though they're still around), the parts we can't do, and the parts we don't feel like doing.

It's "How can anyone claim obeying God's law is no longer necessary," over here, and it's "The ceremonial and national laws are no longer in force," over there. It's, "Not one jot or one tittle," when we're talking about the Sabbath day, and it's, "Jesus paid the price," when I ask them where they source their turtledoves for sacrifice. I've dubbed this "The Legalist Dance".

Not one jot or one tittle from the eternal law has changed in any way, except....












************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Which Law

Even in the secular world, the idea; the thought of running a country without laws to regulate and deal with evils and crime would be unthinkable.

This mindset translates over into the theological world, where religions have religious laws where the adherents could find themselves at odds with their theological brothers and sisters.

When the Christian Scriptures speak about Christians no longer being under the law, some recoil in disbelief, for the concept is totally foreign to their way of thinking.

Two things are not perceived or understood properly. The Christian is not under the law because of what the law does; how it operates in an environment of evil people who are subject to the punishments of the law regarding sin, where sin gets redefined to mean specific “crimes” against the law. This is not how that previous law of the letter operates. It addresses anything that meets the criteria of being a sin, and condemns the sinner, and the criteria far exceeds the transgressions of the commandments contained in the law.

In the NT writings “sin” is translated from the Greek word “hamartia” which is quite appropriate in defining sin, that being “missing the mark” as further stated to be in relation to the righteousness and glory of God. In 1John 3:4, following the Greek, “hamartia” sin is further defined as “anomia” being any evil, any iniquity, any violation of law; any law that deals with evil and iniquity, but contextually the law of the old covenant, where, according to verse 5, it is about Jesus taking away our sins by paying the debt for sin, found in the OC law, where sin is universal and not restricted to that law.

Jesus paid the penalty for ALL sin; all evil; all iniquity; all ‘lawlessness’ related to the ‘works of one’s hands’; criminal activity.

That however is not the end of the story, for there still exists the element of an evil heart, and Christ has the solution to this also. It is called:

A LAW OF FAITH AND THE SPIRIT. Which is God Himself where the Holy Spirit is given to those who pledge their allegiance to Him, through faith in Him, ONLY. This is that “new heart” spoken of in the Scriptures that replaces the “heart of stone” all are born with; that evil and deceptive, unbelieving heart.

Now ask yourself the logical, critical thinking question, as to why those who embrace the old covenant law, whittled down to just the Decalogue, would insist that should this older law end, this would result in a condition of their being a vacuum of law; the non-existence of law; a state of “antinomianism?”
The answer lies within the declaration made by God regarding the condition of those with evil hearts.

(Jeremiah 17:9) The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?

The evil hearted use the law as a cloak for their evil hearts, where they define sin as being limited to the “transgression of the law” following the flawed English translation that ignores the Greek.

Take away that law, and you remove the cloak where sin defined as the transgression of the law, meaning just the Decalogue. They can do what the Pharisees and others did with the law. Give the appearance of keeping it, so that the conclusion is drawn that they are free of sin, where they do not openly transgress it. Even the Apostle Paul states that he, as an active, practicing Pharisee; when it came to the law and keeping it, he was blameless, but after his conversion saw how it was all a sham; a righteousness of filth.

That law serves those who embrace that law. They use it to appear sinless, while sating their evil hearts through accusations and condemnation served out to those who refuse to join them in their dissimulation.

Jesus was the greatest threat they ever had to deal with, and they dealt with Him through the law; manipulating it; administering it, all the while giving the appearance of carrying out God’s will through the law… a win-win for the evil Pharisees, who, according to Jesus, were children of the devil, doing the will of their father the devil while looking good and upright, according to the law.

The devil still has his evil children doing his will, and why would it surprise anyone today that the children of the devil would be doing the exact same thing their evil predecessors did, using that law to their own advantage and to discourage people from embracing the new covenant law of life, led now by the Holy Spirit, and not that older law?

It is as the Martyr Stephen pointed out:

(Acts 7:51) Ye stiffnecked and uncircumcised in heart and ears, ye do always resist the Holy Ghost: as your fathers did, so do ye.

Those that preceded them, along with them, and those of today. All resisting the Holy Spirit, embracing the law of condemnation and death, engraven in stones, redefining it now as the New Covenant law of God, denying any other law of faith and the Spirit.

Paul referred to the old covenant law as not of faith. It cannot be both a law not of faith and the New Covenant law of faith.

Condemnation and death are related to the old covenant law. Life is related to Christ and following Him and those things He said and taught.

(Romans 8:2) For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus hath made me free from the law of sin and death.

************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Graven Images

(Exodus 20:1-6) I am the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage. Thou shalt have no other gods before me. Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image, or any likeness of any thing that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth: °Thou shalt not bow down thyself to them, nor serve them: for I the LORD thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth generation of them that hate me; °And shewing mercy unto thousands of them that love me, and keep my commandments.

The first thing here is the preeminence of God. Then follows a ban on graven images, whether they are intended to be a representation of God or not. The gilded calf they created while Moses was on the mount they referred to as the God that brought them out of Egypt.

They were commanded not to make ANY graven image; the likeness of anything in heaven, earth, or beneath the sea. It doesn’t get much more comprehensive than that, but with one curious observation as to what substance man could use, found in all three realms, that could be used to create and fashion a graven image.

Stone.

These two tablets “written with the finger of God” were smashed by Moses before the people ever saw them in a state other than rubble. God instructed Moses to carve out of stone replacement tablets, first telling Moses He, God, would write upon them what was written on the original set, then it turns out Moses was later, after fashioning the tablets, that He was to write upon them what was written on the first set.

What resulted was “graven images of stone” made by one of them; not God, who commanded what? “YOU” shall not make unto you any graven image…

From this law set; the two graven images of stone, the Jews used them to destroy the very God who thundered out these commandments from Mt. Sinai; God Incarnate who walked among them, in the flesh. They PROVED beyond any doubt that these graven images of stone were to them their god — graven images, made by one of them, being Moses, made of the material found in the three realms mentioned by God.

This, again, is the same God who commanded their forefathers, passed down to them, to hold to him exclusively; the God that provided their “salvation” from Egypt. And in this particular commandment, a statement that he would visit their iniquity upon their children due to their hatred of Him, God.
(John 15:24) If I had not done among them the works which none other man did, they had not had sin: but now have they both seen and hated both me and my Father.

Those works of God were often carried out on the Sabbath; a law engraved in stone images.
Their iniquity was in putting God Incarnate to death, using the law; the Decalogue specifically; their “other god besides (along side of; in conjunction with) God, and their children paid the price for their iniquity a generation later, and beyond, starting in 70 AD with the destruction of the Temple and Jerusalem where an estimated one million Jews perished according to Josephus.

Those Hebrews that left Egypt would not listen to God. God gave them the law through Moses; the mediator of that law, so that they would remember and listen to Moses “for ever” with a law that would result in their condemnation.

(Exodus 19:9) And the LORD said unto Moses, Lo, I come unto thee in a thick cloud, that the people may hear when I speak with thee, and believe thee for ever. And Moses told the words of the people unto the LORD.

(Romans 7:10) And the commandment, which was ordained to life, I found to be unto death.
The Hebrews embraced the law because they thought there was something to be gained, that being blessings. But simply embracing the law; the Decalogue; the “graven images of stone” they were cursed.

Notice now the parallel.

Eve was convinced by the devil to partake of God’s tree; embrace it, because she too perceived there was something to gain, but by just eating of it; its fruit, she brought upon herself condemnation, ultimately because she didn’t believe God. She wasn’t listening to God; she was listening to the devil. Her inner desires drove her to partake of that tree, thinking there was something of value to gain.

Today, there are those still trying to get people to “obey” the law; “follow” the law, selling the law on the idea that there is something to gain by doing so, when it is the one’s selling the law that have something to gain through the law; a following and what follows such a choice, to the benefit of those administering the law, even as the Pharisees profited through the administration of the law.

Those who have been convinced to embrace the law vehemently defend the law, insisting it is “God’s law” where the same argument could be used by pointing out that the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was “God’s tree.” And like those Hebrews at Mt. Sinai, such people place their faith, trust, and belief in the law; the law that produces wrath — the law that makes ALL guilty before God — the law that gives strength to sin, so that sin condemns in concert with the law — the law of sin and death — the ministration of condemnation and death, engraved in stones.

The irony today is that the law is sold as the means to avoid sin, when simply embracing the law; the Decalogue; the graven images of stone, was, and is to sin. An act of faithlessness with God through an act of faith in the law of two graven images, with the Sabbath, by analogy, cut deeper into the surface. Or, as EGW wrote, where a “special aura” encapsulated the Sabbath commandment that was used by the Pharisees to condemn and destroy God.

God placed that tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the garden of Eden to test Adam and Eve; whether they would follow Him and listen to Him, or ignore Him and listen to another; believe another. It is the same scenario played out with the Decalogue, where Jesus came with the same proposition: Believe in Him. Trust Him. Have faith in Him, with the alternative there, providing the choice; the alternative that looks attractive, and where it is perceived there is a benefit to be had; a wisdom, even as Eve concluded.


************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The Misunderstood Beast Power

A brief and unorthodox look at the prophetic Beast. 

America has had a mid-term election and, as usual, party control has switched. Some people are very happy while others are very sad. Somehow, the "I love heads" team and the "I love tails" team manage to keep believing their side of the coin is somehow fundamentally different than the other side of that very same coin. We've flipped that coin several times in the past. How's that goin' for ya?

These are the times when Armstrongist "ministers" tend to bark about prophetic fulfillment and the Great Tribulation. Fear is a great way to raise funds. Make no mistake, it's all about the funds.

I very much dislike prophecy. I used to love it. Practically obsessed with it. It's the main thing that got me into Armstrongism in the first place. Not. Any. More. But I'm jaded with the world once again, I am reminded this is not my home, and my heart yearns for that Kingdom we were created to inhabit, and my heart sighs and cries for all the confusion in the world, and so I thought I might explore prophecy just a teensy bit. Today I talk prophecy stuff.

I want to point something out that you rarely if ever hear in an Armstrongist church. If you've read this blog for any length of time then you know I love to throw a good curveball. I try to look at things from different directions.

I am not promising you anything specific, other than a different perspective. I do not claim to have any solid answers in this game. I remind you, dear reader, that all prophetic interpretation is speculation.

Here's your curveball stated plainly:
The Beast isn't completely bad. You might even like it.

"What!?! xHWA, now I know you've gone mental." No, no. Hear me out. I'm not advocating for the Beast power; I'm trying to warn you.

THE BENEVOLENT BEAST

You all know the prophecies. I'm not going to belabor the point. Daniel 2. Statue. Head of gold, etc etc. Daniel 7. Four beasts - Babylon, Persia, Greece, Rome.

These were real kingdoms in history. Sermons and articles on these things concentrate on the negative aspects of these kingdoms. They're scary. They're dangerous. It makes for better story telling that way (and better fundraising). But have you ever considered the good aspects of these kingdoms? Don't tell me there were no good aspects, because you know there were.

Have you ever read Daniel 4:34-37? I bet you have. It's in the book of Daniel, but it wasn't written by Daniel. Those verses were written by none other than King Nebuchadnezzar II ... king of the head of gold and the first beast. The very first great king of the very first portion of the Beast wrote some of the most beautiful words praising God that you will find in the entire Bible. There were miracles. Some of the greatest names in the Bible held top positions. Yet this kingdom did not stop being the first beast of Daniel.

Have you ever read II Chronicles 36:22-23, or the book of Ezra? It was none other than Cyrus, king of the chest and arms of silver and the second beast, who returned Israel from exile to its homeland and facilitated the rebuilding of the Temple of God in Jerusalem. The beast did that. The second beast returned the golden items looted by Nebuchadnezzar II from the Temple of God, for the worship of God. But it wasn't just Cyrus, it was God acting through Cyrus. The Almighty God acted through the beast. Later, when the Gentile people whom the Assyrians brought into the land of Israel tried to stop the building of the Temple, King Darius ordered them to leave the effort alone and even ordered them to help fund it. In Ezra 6, three kings of the second beast are credited with helping the effort to rebuild the Temple: Cyrus, Darius, and Artaxerxes. Have you ever looked at it that way before?

Alexander the Great, the belly and thighs of bronze and greatest king of the third beast, arguably the greatest single king of them all, didn't do amazing things for Israel, but he did some very good things and he was quite tolerant of them. He allowed the Temple services to remain, he never defiled the Temple, he raised the standard of living in the region, and he exempted Israel from taxes every seventh year for the sabbatical year. The people liked him so much that it even became a tradition for a while in Israel to name their firstborn sons Alexander.
And then, 148 years after Alexander died, Antiochus IV Epiphanes came to power.

Until that whole business with the destruction of the Temple and the Bar Kokhba Revolt, Rome actually did some very good things for Israel. I will quote a Monty Python skit from the highly irreverent comedy "Life of Brian" where a Jewish nationalist front group inadvertently creates a list of good things Rome did for them:

"All right, but apart from the sanitation, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, a fresh water system, and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?
Brought peace.
Oh, peace? Shut up!"

Truth is, Rome actually did some of these things.

Why did Rome conquer Israel in the first place? Judas Maccabee led a revolt that eventually resulted in an independent Jewish kingdom, established under his brother Simon. For a brief period, Israel ruled itself. What did it do with that opportunity? A series of internal power struggles and civil wars. Two warring rulers of Judaea appealed to Pompey of Rome for support against each other. Pompey ordered them to stop fighting while he came to a decision. They would not. So, Pompey marched in, eventually bringing Judea under Roman domination. In time, Rome installed Herod the Great as king. How did that go? You know the story. When Herod died, Rome divided his kingdom among his sons. A few years later, Rome took direct control of Judea. Why did they take direct control? Because Archelaus was such a terrible ruler that a delegation of Jewish leaders traveled to Rome and appealed to Augustus. They accused Archelaus of cruelty and tyranny and asked that he be removed. In 6 AD, Augustus accommodated the request. So, you see, the Beast was actually, in its own way, trying to bring peace and order to a land that repeatedly refused it. That is not to say Rome was friendly. It was cruel. The taxation was bitter, the laws harsh, and the rulers oppressive. In 66 AD, after nearly a century of putting up with Rome, the Jews finally revolted ...and the Temple was destroyed; not one stone left upon another. 

You can respond to me with all the horrid things each of these kingdoms did in the region, and you would be absolutely correct. They were each terrible in many ways. But none of that erases from history these positive things each of those kingdoms did. My point is not to paint them as wonderful. They weren't. My point is simply to say they each did good things as well as bad. Each were loved as well as hated.

MOVING FORWARD

It seems there might be another iteration of this Beast Power to emerge towards the end of this age. (Speculation!) Revelation. Seven heads; ten horns. You know the one. If the Beast Power that you have in your mind is all evil and oppressive all the time, so obvious in its machinations that you'll see it coming from miles away - rising from the sea and stamping its terrible feet and gnashing its terrible teeth - then chances are good it already has you fooled.

There will be no Sunday Law. There will be no 'all evil all the time'. No. It will come so much more subtly than that (or, perhaps, has already come). Satan comes as an angel of light. The Beast will not just appear all of a sudden at the end of the age and immediately get down to the business of oppressing the faithful. I gave you the examples I did above to demonstrate that the Beast can build a Temple of God, too. In theory, some of those who have looked for it their whole lives might end up on Team Beast, not realizing it.

There is a second character, pictured as a woman.

What is the main accusation against Babylon the Great? Luxury. Luxury from successful commerce. A life so good that the people forget God. Luxury and excess is not the kind of oppression most people anticipate. Who would ever cry out, "Oh no! Not a system where I can live greater than the dreams of most kings!" ??  (I am not suggesting luxury is inherently bad, nor that all people will be bathed in luxury. I am merely saying if you forget God in the good times, then you're in danger.)

I wrote an article years ago that shows the many parallels between this woman and Israel. That was not to say Israel is this woman, but there are remarkable parallels which prove you can be God's own elect nation and yet be practically indistinguishable from something like this.

At first, the luxurious woman rides the Beast. At first, the Beast goes along with luxury and excess. There are good times for all. She knows it's a Beast, but thinks she can control it forever. It knows she's a harlot, but it tolerates her. Inevitably, there must be a clash. It turns on her. She loses.

One system that delivers luxury from international commerce vs another system which uses that commerce but in its heart opposes it. Both anti-God at their cores. Both capable of horrible evils, but yet good things as well. Neither are all evil all the time. God's people live in both, and hopefully understand both systems oppose God. Neither of those two options are the right choice.

Any system that is opposed to Jesus, which sells itself as opposed to wealth (except for the leadership, of course), which promises a better way to meet all your needs, and which allies itself with a false religion, probably ought to be be suspect #1 in your mind.
Not the only suspect, but the prime suspect.

Anything that claims it can solve your problems through wealth and trade, apart from the God who gives blessings and increase, probably ought to be suspect in your mind.

Look around you. What if both the "I love heads" team and the "I love tails" team are wrong?

It is well within reason to assume the description of the Beast which Herbert Armstrong preached was just as wrong as his hundreds of other failed prophecies and predictions, made, "by the AUTHORITY of JESUS CHRIST, the living HEAD of the TRUE CHURCH OF GOD!" (his words, not mine). If you are still following that pattern, you might want to reconsider.

"Hitler is the 'Beast' of Revelation.... There, Bible prophecy does indicate that Hitler must be the victor in his present Russian invasion."
-Herbert W. Armstrong, The Plain Truth, October 1941, p. 7.

Yeahhhh. So...

This idea of what the Beast will be was set by people who lived in the 1800s. Wars between great powers aren't even done that way anymore. Not at first. We fight proxy wars. We use misinformation, propaganda, subterfuge, economic pressure, hackers, rioters, electoral interference, politics and ambassadors. It is long past time to consider looking at the world from anther point of view.

CONCLUSION

I am not predicting anything specific. I am not identifying the Beast of Revelation as anything specific. I am setting zero dates. Predictions and identifications and dates are above my pay grade. I am no prophet. I am not the end-time [insert title here] for to come. No angel named Zamboni, or Boloney, or whatever, came to give me a message for you. I do not want your tithes and offerings.

What I am saying here in this post is simply that, just like when Jesus came the first time, things might not be as people expect. We may have misunderstood the Beast. We may have a certain picture in our minds of how things will be but what comes to pass might not match our picture, and so we could fail to recognize the danger. Or, what we look for finally comes, but we realize it so late that we are already in the path of the tsunami before we grasp what's been going on. Israel had steeped in the third beast for 150 years before Antiochus.

Seeing as all this is completely out of our power no matter how it happens, I recommend doing precisely what the Bible recommends: be alert, keep your eyes open to every possibility, and above all stay faithful. God didn't spare Ezekiel and Daniel from captivity. What did they do while in captivity? Make it all about themselves? No. They remained faithful and praised God, who was still in control and whose will was being worked out here below.



************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Sin is What?

Despite what you were told about God’s judgment, He does not judge according to the law; He judges according to the heart, where an evil heart is condemned by the law. For an evil heart is a sinful heart, and the law condemns sins because they are evil. This is the point being made in 1John 3:4, obscured by the early English translation that slipped into interpretation based on common misconception.

Sin ALSO transgresses the law. This is what is established to begin with in 1John 3:4, then clarification follows: … for sin is “anomia” that being the Greek word translated and understood in English as “evil” and/or “iniquity” as well as transliterated as “against law” in Greek as evil and iniquitous acts are “against law” in a generic sense, and not the specific sense regarding the Hebrew old covenant Decalogue.

Sin, being evil and iniquity, transgresses the law, producing the wrath of the law and the guilt derived by and through the law.

Any evil; any iniquity, is sin that in turn transgresses the law, resulting in the condemnation of the law. The flawed translation in the KJV results in a rendering that eliminates evil and iniquitous things unless specifically addressed by the old covenant law. And when some Sabbatarians such as Adventists further define and restrict the law to mean just the Decalogue, many evils and iniquities are ignored, swept under a theological rug, so that an evil and iniquitous heart is not condemned by ‘the law’.

It is a subtle alteration of the Scriptures, worthy of a deceitful heart desperately trying to hide behind a modified understanding of sin that exempts wicked hearts.

A deceitful and desperately wicked heart will attempt denial in this regard, which is interesting, for it is like trying to convince yourself God has no interest in a wicked heart, as long as those with wicked hearts keep the law, as did the Pharisees whom Jesus stated were destined for hell.

(Matthew 23:33) Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell?

They kept the Decalogue. They kept the Sabbath. And, they neglected the weightier matters of the law; “judgment” [justice] mercy, and faith.

Make special note of that. The weightier matters of the law; the important things; the essential things in the law ARE NOT LOCATED IN THE DECALOGUE found in those specific commandments.

So why do Sabbatarian Adventists single them out and isolate them from the rest of the law? They claim is it due to those specific commandments being “moral” in nature, as contrasted to the balance of the law, deemed ceremonial. In this division of law, where do you find justice, mercy, and faith? They are actually further obscured, especially with the Sabbath command that even those same Pharisees condemned Christ Jesus, mercilessly.

Judgment, tempered by mercy and faith, is nowhere to be found in a religion restricted to the Decalogue and a definition of sin that is based on any transgression of those commandments. It is an automatic declaration of sin and condemnation without any mercy or faith applied. It is ruthless judgment and condemnation for having violated those commandments, especially the Sabbath. Work on the Sabbath and you are guilty of sin, because to work on the Sabbath is to break the Sabbath, and breaking is transgressing, and that is sin, period. You hear and read this response on a near daily basis.

Jesus’ response to a charge of sin leveled on Him for working on the Sabbath was that good works are lawful on the Sabbath which fell on deaf ears, attached to deceitful and desperately wicked hearts that has no interest in just judgment, mercy, and faith, and where Adventism has effectively eliminated this aspect of the law from their interpretation of the law, being solely the Decalogue.

Neglecting the weightier matters of the law; judgment, mercy, and faith necessary for righteous judgment and justice… is that a sin? Or is this excluded by a “belief” that insists only those transgressions of the law; the Decalogue are sin?

It’s all about excluding and ignoring evil, iniquitous hearts.


************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Fruits of the Spirit; Works of the law

Jesus referred to the people as evil. He referred to the Pharisees as evil children of the Devil, doing the will of their father the devil.

They called Jesus a servant of the Devil, performing miracles by the power of the Devil.

If you were there; one of the people Jesus spoke to, and heard Him refer to you as evil, how would you respond within yourself? Wouldn’t you naturally conclude He was mistaken; that you are not evil, like so many other people about you? It begs the question as to whether you would consider something God said through the psalms:

(Psalms 53:3) Every one of them is gone back: they are altogether become filthy; there is none that doeth good, no, not one.

The Pharisees believed themselves to be good, relying on the law. They kept the law. They taught the law. For Jesus to declare them evil children of the Devil, doing the will of their father the Devil, would have been seen as just the ravings of an itinerant preacher who was seeking a personal following, and when miracles started popping up performed by Him, they concluded He was more than just another unlearned self-proclaimed prophet; that He was a real threat with the backing of the Devil behind Him… all the more reason to stop Him.

At this juncture, you have a requirement to evaluate the situation. If you believe Jesus was the Messiah, the Christ, then you must accept what He said, and He called the Pharisees and Sanhedrin evil children of the Devil doing the will of their father the Devil, and that they taught the law and administered it. Jesus even called them out on their practice of traversing land and sea to make a proselyte, resulting in those people becoming twice the children of hell than they were… quite an indictment.

To the Pharisees and man on the street, Jesus flaunted the law… the “law of God”. To Jesus, He was flaunting their feigned obeisance to the law. They used the law as cover; a cloak to disguise their evil hearts and deeds.

(Mark 7:6) He answered and said unto them, Well hath Esaias prophesied of you hypocrites, as it is written, This people honoureth me with their lips, but their heart is far from me.

They went through the religious motions, for the sake of appearance, putting on a good show of being dedicated to keeping the law, while the God who gave them that law stood before them.

What then can we learn from all this? That evil people will put on a show of piety using the law as part of their costume. Evil people have deceptive hearts, and they innately see the potential to use the law as the means of best concealing it. A truly good person, led by the Holy Spirit, has no need for such a facade. Their actual good works, wrought in and through the Holy Spirit, speak for themselves. It is actions that follow conscience of the good hearted. Contrast this to those whose evil hearts are cloaked by the law, where they do the works of the law, and conclude those are the evidence of their goodness and acceptance by God.

Those who follow Christ; those who are now His, keep His commandments that revolve around love, faith, and the Spirit; not the works of the law.

(Galatians 2:16) Knowing that a man is not justified by the works of the law, but by the faith of Jesus Christ, even we have believed in Jesus Christ, that we might be justified by the faith of Christ, and not by the works of the law: for by the works of the law shall no flesh be justified.

Those led by the flesh and not the Spirit have no option but to attempt and use the works of the law to appear justified, for they cannot produce the actual fruits of the Spirit.

Sabbatarians emphasize the Sabbath for this sole purpose. They see it as fruit of the Spirit as well as a work of the law, with the added benefit of having an outlet for their evil through accusations of sin and evil against others who recognize the Sabbath as an impediment to actual fruits of the Spirit - literally violating the very law they claim to cherish and obey by bearing the most egregious false witness against their neighbor - where Paul specifically stated there is no law against the fruits or works of the Spirit, and that includes the Sabbath law.

Good works were declared lawful on the Sabbath by the Lord of the Sabbath. And by the dissolution of the old covenant, and the establishment of the new for those led by the Holy Spirit, the Sabbath day was done away with, even as God foretold through the prophets.


************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************