Saturday, November 21, 2026

Not One Jot, Except...

Old Covenant legalists insist that God's law remains unchanged, but they can't seem to agree on which laws we're supposed to keep, which ones have disappeared, or how the whole thing is supposed to work. Apparently, not one jot or tittle has changed, except for all the exceptions.

I was once an Armstrongist. I genuinely thought they had their doctrine correct. I lived it, taught it, sacrificed so much for it, and will live the rest of my days with the repercussions of it. I never saw, or rather never admitted, the flaws in the system until I gave myself permission to ask questions. I left the group after the inconsistencies became too numerous and serious to pretend like they did not matter.

What really floors me these days is that the issues just keep right on coming; not only from Armstrongism but from other legalist groups.

They all say, "The law! The law!" But they don't agree with one another on why we are all bound to the law, or even what laws we are bound to. They explain their competing systems in many ways which do not agree with one another. Does the law apply to us because we join physical Israel, or does the law apply to us because it applies to everyone? One says we are bound to all the moral law and some of the ceremonial law, another says we are bound to the Ten Commandments only and some of the ceremonial law, and yet another says the Ten Commandments are the whole law.
"...just not THAT law."

This is the kind of issue I want to examine today. Because it keeps coming up, over and over again.

NOTHING HAS CHANGED EXCEPT WHAT HAS CHANGED

I will start by reminding you of my post "One Jot or One Tittle", where we reviewed one of Sabbatarianism's favorite proof-texts:

(MAT. 5: 17-18) 17 Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill. 18 For assuredly, I say to you, til heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from the law til all is fulfilled.

Not one jot or one tittle. Not one cross of the T or dot of the I. Sabbatarians believe this selection means all the whole law is still in force, all of it, 'til heaven and earth pass away.
...except for that 97% of the law that they believe is not necessary. Every T and I, except for those ones. Naturally.

The image says the law is the truth and asks, "How can anyone claim obeying His law is no longer necessary?"
3% of the time, the law is unchanged every time.

Herbert Armstrong himself, in the Plain Truth Magazine, September 1959, p.5, quotes Matthew 5:17-18, but he immediately deflects to it referring to the Ten Commandments. Garner Ted Armstrong used it to support tithing. Herman Hoeh used it to claim the Bible is accurate and God's word has been preserved. Rod Meredith used it to say we can keep the law with the help of the Holy Spirit.

Apparently, Matthew 5:17-18 can mean anything we need it to.

But at the end of the day, Jesus only leaves two options: either all the law is 100% in force, or all the law has been fulfilled. If any point has passed from the law, and most legalist groups say it has, then guess what that means ... all has been fulfilled. Sabbatarians take both options.

I know someone will say to me, "Fulfilled does not mean removed." This is absolutely correct.  ' Fulfill' and 'remove' are not the same. Jesus lived to fulfill it and died to remove it. But this objection demonstrates my point. 

Jesus said He came to fulfill it. He did. Jesus, the True Israel, kept it all on Israel's behalf. He fulfilled the law. He is the law-keeper. If it is not fulfilled, then what part(s) did Jesus miss, who will fulfill it, and when?
He is also the primary party to the Old Covenant. When He died, that Covenant dissolved. The phrase "til all is fulfilled" implies it will be removed after it is fulfilled. If the law cannot be removed, then why does everyone have parts they've removed? Not a jot or tittle can be removed until it's all fulfilled ... and yet we've removed whole swaths, therefore we all agree it has been fulfilled. Yes?
In all actuality, Sabbatarians are trying to have this one both ways and neither.

Chief among removed laws are the ones that make it abundantly clear the law as for Israel alone. The Ten Commandments were specifically for Israel, the people who were saved from Egypt and were on their way to the land the Lord was giving them. It's right there in the first sentence of the Decalogue. Or just look at the fifth Commandment:

(EXO. 20:12) Honor your father and your mother, that your days may be long upon the land which the Lord your God is giving you.

Is it a moral and good thing to honor your father and mother? Yes! But will it lead to your land-blessings in Israel? Not so much. We cannot simply pretend like the second half of that Commandment does not exist.

The Ten were written for and given to Israel. If the law is not changed, then this reality is not changed. These Gentile Sabbatarians must first make fundamental alterations in the law to get it to apply to the whole world and themselves before they can turn around and accuse everyone of not keeping the list of laws they created for themselves. Except it isn't theirs to make lists from.

Either the law is 100% in force, or it isn't. But if it isn't, then we cannot quote Matthew like it is. Claiming fulfilled does not mean destroyed is correct, but rather contradictory when taking both sides at the same time.

RITUALLY SACRIFICED

Another person told me this:

"The law of sin and death didn't change; only the source of the blood that atones for our sin."

To which I replied, "That's a change." And a big one.
Do you see how this person has taken both sides? The law has not changed at all ...except where it has. 

The point in that quote, you see, is that the "ceremonial law" is gone. Old Covenant legalists do not want the whole law, only some laws. So, they work hard to keep the laws they want and jettison the laws they do not want. Because it's useful, they accept the division of the law into moral, ceremonial, and national laws, Then they remove the ceremonial and national ones. The ceremonial ones were replaced by Jesus, they say, and the national ones were only for Israel. (Except they were all only for Israel, but I digress.) But the moral ones stay unchanged, they say.

Which ones are the moral laws? I have yet to witness any Sabbatarian provide a coherent definition for what a "moral law" even is. They tell us the moral laws remain in force. Fantastic! Which are those, exactly? They won't say. I tried to research it on my own. The Bible doesn't say. Why not? Because the Bible does not divide the law into these three categories, and the individual laws do not always fit those three categories neatly. What even is a "moral law", exactly? They won't commit to a definition. Mainly because that definition would exclude the Sabbath day. (But that is for another article.)

Even though the individual laws do have those qualities, I do not subscribe to splitting the law into three categories. Why not? Because the Bible never recognizes these as legal categories. The Bible never says anything of the sort. The body of Old Covenant law is a single, indivisible whole and the 613 laws are the terms of that covenant. Even though the individual laws do have those qualities (not all fit neatly), that is no excuse to use those qualities to divide the Covenant up and toss out parts.

Hey! What happened to Matthew 5:17-18?

Someone might say to me, "But Hebrews makes it clear the ceremonial parts are gone." OK. I agree, it does. And they are. I believe it shows a lot more than that. It shows the whole covenant was replaced.

And again, dividing the law up and tossing parts out is just a wordier way to say, "Not one jot or one tittle, except..."

WHAT'S ON THE INSIDE

Here is an actual quote pulled verbatim straight from social media:

"The New Covenant was never meant to be the death of the Torah. It was the internalizing of it. ... The Torah is not a shadow of the past; it is the light for our path, now shining from the inside out. That is the power of the New Covenant."

Translation: The power of the New Covenant is that it's exactly the same as the Old Covenant in every way, only fundamentally different.
Magnificent!

Disregard that this person writes Torah when they mean Old Covenant law. Torah is a lot more than law. A rookie mistake, but I'm not here to nitpick.

What I cannot simply disregard, however, is that I have yet to witness any Old Covenant legalist give a satisfactory explanation for what "the law, internalized" actually is, in the real world. For example, how do I, every seventh day, have physical rest internally? How do we build a booth internally? Do we internally sacrifice turtledoves? Do our tefillin shine through from the inside? Do we spiritually have a son of Aaron as our High Priest with a miter and ephod? How do we get fabrics inside of us, but then prevent them from mixing together?

In the real world, saying, "The letter of the Old Covenant law unchanged but it is inside us," is completely incoherent.

I took the quote above from a much longer statement. It was clear the intent was to say the New Covenant does nothing to remove the Old Covenant law. There is a problem with this: that must include ALL of the law, even the ceremonial and national laws, which have been tossed out.

You may think I'm being ridiculous in my questions above, and perhaps I am, but remember, I am not the one claiming the law has to be 100% intact and unchanged except that it's fundamentally changed and internalized. So, am I really being ridiculous, or am I merely pointing out the ridiculous?

If you want another way to understand the law being internalized, read "The Law Is Written On Our Hearts - Part I".

WHO SAT ON THE REMOTE?

Go ahead and ask an Old Covenant legalist about these internal incoherencies. All you will get is more incoherency. How do I know? Because I've been trying it for years.

Here is an actual quote pulled verbatim straight from social media. Someone mentioned that we must keep the Sabbath now because Isaiah says we will keep the Sabbath in the future. I mentioned about how Isaiah said we would ride chariots to collect Levites to serve at the temple, and asked if that means Christians should have the Levitical Priesthood with the Aaronic Priest today? They said:

"It's not an ending, but a pause. Even after Jesus returned to heaven the early Christians were still bringing offerings and sacrifices to the Temple."

So, the ceremonial law is not gone but on pause. Someone should tell that to the author of Hebrews. When we find the remote and finally un-pause, will we have two High Priests? 

This person's point was that there is no Temple, so we can't do those things today. That's not entirely correct. The Temple may be gone but the Levites went nowhere. There are parts of the law which require a Levite but do not require the Temple (e.g., unsolved murders, skin disease inspections, inspections for contamination of homes or clothes, etc)? What happens to these laws? Why are they on pause? And perhaps most pertinent of all, what happens to tithing? It was primarily for the Levites. How can a "Minister" accept tithes when it's supposed to be for the Levites, and those laws are not removed? Someone owes back payments!

The author mentioned James advising Paul to shave his head and pay for four men who had taken a vow, which we see in Acts 21. And, yes, there usually was some sort of sacrifice at the end of a vow (usually, but not always). There are several problem here:

  • What Jewish converts in Jerusalem were doing prior to the Temple's destruction is not an indicator of what everyone should be doing today, let alone when Christ returns.
  • Anyone who uses Acts 21 to claim the Jewish converts were zealous for the law and therefore we should be zealous for the law (which would be most if not all Sabbatarian groups), must remember that includes animal sacrifice.
  • This does not constitute an endorsement of animal sacrifice, or a Jewish Temple, or the human High Priest in the New Covenant era.
  • We cannot simply ignore that James was bluntly specific when he said, "But concerning the Gentiles who believe, we have written and decided that they should observe no such thing..." (v25). (For more, see "Acts 15 - What Was Debated?")

I remind you that this part of Isaiah 66 is a prophecy, and all prophetic interpretation is speculation (even my own). It is a terrible idea to build doctrine on speculation. Yet, I believe a literal interpretation falls completely apart if we approach it in a neutral way, without trying to force it to support a certain predetermined conclusion. We go into this in the post "The Sabbath Rest of Isaiah 66".

CONCLUSION

I trust by now that you see how this game is played. "The law is eternal and unchanged," but not the ceremonial law, the national law, the parts that specify Israel and exclude Gentiles, the parts that require a Temple, the parts that require a Levite (even though they're still around), the parts we can't do, and the parts we don't feel like doing.

It's "How can anyone claim obeying God's law is no longer necessary," over here, and it's "The ceremonial and national laws are no longer in force," over there. It's, "Not one jot or one tittle," when we're talking about the Sabbath day, and it's, "Jesus paid the price," when I ask them where they source their turtledoves for sacrifice. I've dubbed this "The Legalist Dance".

Not one jot or one tittle from the eternal law has changed in any way, except....












************

It is important that you understand; Everything on this blog is based on the current understanding of each author. Never take anyone's word for it, always prove it for yourself, it is your responsibility. You cannot ride someone else's coattail into the Kingdom. ; )

Acts 17:11

************

No comments:

Post a Comment